BBN_typestyle_-_pastel.png__PID:6df2f6eb-2ac9-40b0-bbc2-3478805b52bb

Your Cookies, Your Way –
Mix & Match Your Perfect Box

Choose any 6 New York-style gourmet cookies & get them delivered fresh • FREE UK Delivery included.

Build My Cookie Box Now

path0.webp__PID:ea54a3c6-926e-46df-ad47-58dd7de31b8f

Craving Real Gourmet Cookies but Stuck with Store-bought Disappointments?

We've all been there. It's frustrating when you're after that perfect indulgent treat, but:

Bored of bland, mass-produced cookies that just don’t satisfy?

Frustrated you can’t get all your favourite flavours in one box?

Tired of paying bakery cafe prices for something that isn’t truly special?

We hear you – it’s hard to find the perfect cookie fix that hits all the right notes… until now.

The Ultimate Personalised
Cookie Experience

Mix & Match Flavours

Pick each cookie in your box. No more settling; get all your favourites every time.

Freshness Guaranteed

Baked to order and sealed for freshness, your cookies arrive soft and delicious as if picked up from the bakery today.

Handcrafted Quality

Our thick New York-style cookies are baked fresh to order with the finest ingredients for unmatched homemade taste.

Great Value

6 giant gourmet cookies for just £21.95 delivered – an indulgence that won’t break the bank (less than £3.70 per cookie, including delivery!).

Perfect for Gifting

Comes in a beautiful gift-ready box. Include a personal note at checkout for a sweet surprise for someone special (or just yourself!).

Free UK Delivery

Enjoy free UK shipping on your box. We bake and dispatch swiftly so your treats arrive ultra-fresh, right to your door.

Build Your Box Now

Loved by Cookie Connoisseurs

jane.png__PID:54a3c692-6e06-4f2d-8758-dd7de31b8f51

Genuinely the best cookies I’ve ever had. The mix-and-match option is a game changer – every flavour was amazing!

Jane D.

aw.png__PID:83e60029-8103-4b87-8114-70c19b2285cf

Ordered a custom box for my office – it disappeared in minutes. Free delivery and top-notch taste, will be reordering for sure.

Aaron W.

What's Inside your Cookie Box?

OUR DELICIOUS FLAVOURS

Biscoff NY Cookie

Chewy cinnamon dough with Lotus Biscoff centers

Classic Chocolate Chip

The quintessential gooey NY cookie, packed with Belgian dark chocolate chunks

White Chocolate & Raspberry

Luxuriously sweet and tangy,
with whole raspberries baked in

Double Chocolate

For the ultimate chocoholic – rich cocoa dough with white and dark chocolate chips

Oatmeal Raisin

Soft, comforting oatmeal cookie with plump, sweet raisins and a hint of spice

Red Velvet

Decadent red velvet cookie with a cream cheese frosting core

IMG-20240514-WA0008_1.jpg__PID:4880720b-b0c5-40a9-8991-fafe9c227c0c

How It Works?

Select Your Cookies
Use our simple form to pick your 6 favourite New York-style cookies (mix or match flavours!).

We Bake Fresh to Order
Our artisan bakers prepare your cookies to order, with care and attention to every box.

Enjoy Free Delivery
Your custom cookie box comes with free UK delivery. Check delivery details at checkout or contact us if you have a specific date in mind.

Handmade

100% Freshness Guaranteed

Frequently Asked Questions

How long will my cookies stay fresh?

They’re best devoured within 5-7 days. We seal each cookie individually for freshness. You can also freeze them on arrival and warm up later – they’ll still taste oven-fresh!

Do you cater to nut or gluten allergies?

Allergen information for our cookie flavours is being reviewed and may be incomplete. If you or your recipient has a food allergy, email enquiries@bakedbynicola.com or call 0800 102 6160 before ordering or eating for the latest flavour-specific information and cross-contact advice. Read our allergen information notice.

What if I need more than 12 cookies or a corporate order?

We’d love to help! For large orders, events, or custom inquiries, drop us a message at hello@bakedbynicola.com. We can accommodate bigger batches and even special packaging for occasions.

What if I’m not satisfied with my order?

If something is not right, email enquiries@bakedbynicola.com with your order number and a description of the problem. Tell us whether you would prefer a replacement, refund or future discount, and we will help make it right. For damaged orders, please tell us promptly and include a photo where possible. Read our terms and conditions. Your statutory rights are not affected.

Is delivery really free? What’s the catch?

Yes, for a box of 6 or 12 cookies, we cover the delivery cost anywhere in the UK. £21.95 is the final price you pay for a 6-cookie box delivered to your door. No hidden fees, no surprise charges. We believe great cookies should come with great service – that includes free shipping.

How big are the cookies?

Our New York-style cookies are thick and generously sized. As our bakes are handmade, size and weight can vary. Contact us for current details.

Still have a question? Contact us and we’ll be happy to help at hello@bakedbynicola.com

Ready to Create Your
Perfect Cookie Box?

Mix & match 6 irresistible cookies, baked fresh and delivered free – it’s a click away